Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Properties
Covered condominium lanai with pale limestone flooring, warm timber soffit, black-framed glass doors, and a sculptural plumeria beside bird's-nest ferns.

Turtle Bay Condo Short-Term Rental Rules Buyers Should Know

October 29, 2026

Two large projects are moving around the Ritz-Carlton Oʻahu, Turtle Bay, and neither one is adding to the supply of vacation-rental units. Kuilima Estates East, Kuilima Estates West and Ocean Villas are existing resort condos in the current rental pool. Taxes have been rising, and a property-tax change is scheduled for 2027.

Vacation Rentals at Kuilima Estates

DPP defines short-term rentals as stays of fewer than 30 consecutive days. It allows them "only in resort-zoned areas and a couple of specific apartment-zoned areas." One of those apartment areas sits next to the resort. Ordinance 25-52 maps the A-1 low-density apartment district "in close proximity to the Turtle Bay Resort" as Figure 21-5.3. The ordinance took effect November 5, 2025. It restored amendments from Ordinance 24-14 that had been left out by mistake, so it did not open new territory.

Kuilima Estates West posts a letter from its AOAO citing an October 5, 2022 board resolution that permits rental "for any period allowed by law, including for transient vacation use." At Kuilima Estates East, the HOA president told Honolulu Civil Beat in May 2025 that about 80% of the complex's 168 units were used as short-term rentals. He said a little more than half of those were registered with the city as of December 2024.

That gap between use and registration matters to a buyer. A unit with a booking history is not necessarily a registered unit, and the eligibility rules are applied parcel by parcel. DPP publishes a Check STR Eligibility map for exactly that. It also has a separate compliance map showing registered properties and those that have received a notice of violation.

Two Projects, and Neither Adds Rental Units

The building activity at Kuilima is real. Here is how each piece relates to the vacation-rental map.

Project Location Status as of late October 2026 Short-term rental role
Host Hotels & Resorts resort, parcel H-1 50 acres at Kawela Bay, west of the Ritz-Carlton Paused for new environmental review after a July 2026 ruling None until it is built
The North Shore Club by Areté Collective East of the resort Construction continuing at all four building sites Developer says short-term rentals are restricted
Kuilima Estates East and West, Ocean Villas Existing resort condos Operating Existing condos in the vacation-rental market

The North Shore Club is the visible change. Civil Beat reported in June that Utah developer Areté Collective bought the land from Blackstone Real Estate in 2024 for $43 million. It began construction on 100 units in August 2025, and the developer wants to build 250 more. Forbes describes the first release as a "20-residence oceanfront enclave" with initial deliveries expected in 2027. The club's own site markets residences from $5.9 million. Areté's October 2026 development update says construction continues on all four building sites.

Areté does not intend these homes to compete for vacation guests. Its chief development officer, Tyler Mills, told Forbes in 2025: "While long-term leasing may be permitted under certain conditions, short-term rentals are restricted to preserve the privacy, exclusivity and strong sense of place that define the experience for our community." That is the developer's stated policy for a private residential club. It means the most expensive new homes at Turtle Bay will sell to a different buyer than a Kuilima condo does.

The Paused Resort Was the Supply Source

The project that could have added hotel and residential inventory near the existing condos is the Host Hotels plan for parcel H-1. As Civil Beat reported on July 15, 1st Circuit Judge Shirley Kawamura found DPP's confirmation letter "arbitrary and capricious." That letter had relied on a 13-year-old supplemental environmental impact statement to clear the plans for 375 residential and hotel units. The judge held that the increased presence of two endangered Hawaiian yellow-faced bees, the nalo meli maoli Hylaeus anthracinus and Hylaeus longiceps, counts as new circumstances under the state's environmental policy act. That requires an updated review.

Civil Beat's June coverage put a new EIS at one to three years. Through the October 23, 2026 issue of the state's Environmental Notice, no new Turtle Bay review has been published. In July, Host Hotels said it was evaluating its options. The company has scheduled its third-quarter results for November 4 and its earnings call for November 5.

A long pause at Kuilima has happened before. A 2010 Hawaiʻi Supreme Court case over an outdated environmental assessment led to cutting Turtle Bay's development plans from up to 3,500 units to 725.

Keeping the Status Costs More Each Year

Rental eligibility is limited, and the taxes on using it have been rising. In order:

  1. January 1, 2026. Under Act 96, the state transient accommodations tax rose from 10.25% to 11%. (State tax announcement)
  2. May 2026. The City and County's Oʻahu Transient Accommodations Tax office began mailing proposed assessments for 2023 tax-year liabilities, with 2024 and 2025 to follow.
  3. July 1, 2027. Ordinance 25-44 resets the property-tax tiers for transient vacation units to up to $900,000, more than $900,000 up to $2 million, and more than $2 million in net taxable value. The Honolulu Board of REALTORS® notes the thresholds had not changed since 2014.

Pricing data cannot settle this yet. Only four condos sold in the whole North Shore region in September 2026, at a $1,047,500 median. That sample is too small to show a premium for rental-eligible units at Turtle Bay or anywhere else. The structural facts above are steadier ground than a single month's median.

The Golf Courses Are Changing Too

The amenities around the condos are also changing. Forbes reported in August that architect David McLay Kidd will renovate Turtle Bay's Arnold Palmer course in phases. Work starts in late 2026 and runs three to four years. Three to five holes will be closed each summer while 18 stay playable, and the original 15th hole will be removed. The course is becoming part of the North Shore Club but will remain open to Ritz-Carlton guests. The resort's other 18-hole course, the Fazio, is closed for improvement projects.

If you plan to rent a condo to golfers, summer listings should describe the course conditions guests will actually find.

Everything above is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm your own situation with a qualified attorney, tax professional or insurance advisor before you act.

If you are weighing a Kuilima Estates or Ocean Villas unit, I'm glad to discuss how the Kawela Bay pause and the Palmer course work affect the property you have in mind. Diego Miranda works with Turtle Bay buyers and sellers in English, Spanish and Portuguese. Let's Connect.

Follow Us On Instagram